Are your medical records still confidential in a divorce case?

The short answer is maybe not. A California appellate court ruled on this issue last week in Manela v. Superior Court, No. B21447. In that action, the parties were in the middle of a dissolution action that included a dispute over child custody. One party moved to quash subpoenas related to their medical records arguing that they were protected by doctor-patient privilege. The lower court had agreed and had, in fact, quashed the subpoenas. But the appellate court reversed the decision ruling that the constitutional right to privacy regarding medical records is not absolute and the party's privacy interests are outweighed by the state's compelling interest in protecting the child's best interests.