Is He/She Going to Have to Keep Paying for Private School Tuition?

Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeals took up this issue last month in the case of Gelman v. Gelman. In this case the parties agreed to a timesharing plan and the Court incorporated that agreement in the final judgment. The Father was ordered to pay child support and a lump sum payment to the Mother instead of alimony and equitable distribution. The Father was also ordered by the Court to pay the children's private school tuition. The Father appealed and argued that the Mother never pled for school tuition. The Mother stated that the agreed upon plan specifically mentioned the private school tuition and that plan was incorporated into the Court's final judgment.

The higher Court reversed the lower Court's ruling and found that the Mother had not specifically pled for it and that there was no evidence to show that the Father had agreed to pay it. Additionally the appellate Court held that the trial Court had not properly analyzed the requirement before imposing a financial responsibility for private school tuition. The Court cited Wilson v. Wilson, 559 So.2d 698 (Fla. 1st DCA 1990) which held that to order private school tuition (1) the parent must have the financial ability to pay it, (2) the expenses must have been in accordance with the family's customary standard of living, and (3) private school must be in the children's best interests.